When Tyler's ball lands over by Mr. Krabs, he asks him to throw the ball back. When asks the kids if can join them he replies to him by saying "Uhh, that's okay. You can keep it. Why do old people always have to ruin the fun?" He then walks away.
He is first seen playing on a new playground, where Mr. Krabs and SpongeBob examine children playing on the playground. Later, he is shown to be excited about Krabby Land but that excitement suddenly changes to disappointment when he sees how cheaply the playground was made. He is shown to down a poorly built slide, which suddenly breaks upon going down. When SpongeBob pretends to be Krabby the Clown's sidekick, the Krabby Patty burglar, he calls it lame. After SpongeBob blows a bubble of a jellyfish, Tyler still calls it lame. After SpongeBob gets his eyes injured when he tries to blow a bubble, Tyler and his friends laugh at SpongeBob's pain. SpongeBob then finds various ways to get himself injured.
Mr. Krabs tries to get a loose quarter, only for Martha to stop him and tell him that it is Tyler's quarter. He then questions Martha if Tyler stole the quarter, and Martha slaps her purse at Mr. Krabs. Tyler then uses it to throw the quarter into the well.