The short starts off with a medieval version of SpongeBob pulling a medieval spatula from a rock. The narrator says that SpongeBob has a gift. SpongeBob becomes a legend with a "cool hairdo" and "biceps."
At night, SpongeBob has a vision of a Krabby Patty and takes a bite to find that this sandwich is the best in the land. He prepares one million Krabby Patties with a secret recipe and gives it to all of the villagers in the land while they all chant his name.
Then, SpongeBob wakes up from his daydream to hear Squidward chanting his name saying that they need a Krabby Patty. SpongeBob then ends the short by saying "Oh, yay verily, Squidward!"
- This short is available on the Legends of Bikini Bottom, Complete Seventh Season, Pilot a Mini-Movie and the Square Shorts, and Next 100 Episodes DVDs.
- When SpongeBob pulls a spatula from a rock, it is a reference to the story A Sword in the Stone, where Arthur pulled Excalibur from a stone and became King of England.