Mr. Krabs tells SpongeBob to make something after he tells Mr. Krabs that he does not remember the formula. SpongeBob attempts to make Krabby Patties, but instead, he makes the New Recipe Krabby Patties. Mr. Krabs says that these patties will have to do.
Fish take the Krabby Patties and SpongeBob says that they are not Krabby Patties, but instead he was experimenting with a new recipe. The fish eat the patties, but soon spit them out towards Squidward.
SpongeBob and Plankton visit Taco Haüs, where Plankton thinks that SpongeBob knows the formula. Since SpongeBob has made many Krabby Patties before and is experienced, Plankton thinks he is able to make more. Afterward, SpongeBob attempts to create a new Krabby Patty recipe, instead of the original. He quickly shows it to Plankton, who then screams loudly, as it does not match to the original Krabby Patty.
Later, after SpongeBob runs away because he thinks he is not a good fry cook, Plankton goes after him and asks where SpongeBob is. The New Recipe Krabby Patty says, "He's down there" and points to a sock. Plankton thanks the New Recipe Krabby Patty, to which it replies "No problem, dude."