He and his orange variant first arrive in a police car and ask Patrick if he has seen the maniac recently by showing him a wanted poster of him, only to have Patrick mistake the drawing as the real maniac. They then show him the poster several times only to get Patrick to scream at the drawing numerous times for their enjoyment.
Later when SpongeBob finds out that he is the maniac, a crowd of multicolored Incidental 118's surround him attempting to send him to jail until Mrs. Puff arrives and reveals to the officers that SpongeBob is her responsibility causing the cops to send her to jail instead of SpongeBob.
He appears as a security guard who is constantly trying to keep Patrick from playing with the displays, and the final straw is when Patrick chases down Jeffrey the Jellyfish; he goes to confront Patrick.
He and his orange variant are at the police station when SpongeBob and Patrick confess that they stole a balloon. They arrest them, but only for a few seconds since it was National Free Balloon Day when they stole the balloon.
He and Cop female drive SpongeBob and Mr. Krabs back to the Krutsy Krab so they can have some Krabby Patties while SpongeBob and Mr. Krabs constantly try to hide the believed dead health inspector from the cops.
He and the orange cop chase after SpongeBob who ran a red light and when they question him if he knows anything about boating safety SpongeBob goes through a long explanation of "boating safety." The police start crying and say it is beautiful. Mrs. Puff says that SpongeBob will have to go to jail and she will not have to teach him anymore. The police explain how she was the one who taught him and they take her to jail, much to her dismay.