ESB:User rights review/Quarterly user rights reviews/7

Open Proposal The following is an ongoing proposal. Please feel free to voice your opinion, but be sure to follow the rules. How proposals work Concerns stage Someone brings up a topic for a proposal. The community discusses that topic. Voting stage The proposal is brought to a vote, taking into account any changes discussed by the community. The community votes. You can use any of the following prior to your comments to show your opinion. {{Support}} • {{Neutral}} • {{Oppose}} • {{Change}} • {{Comment}} • {{Reply}} • {{Question}} Neutral votes do not count in determining the outcome percentage.

Introduction

This is Quarterly user rights reviews (formerly known as "administrator reviews," but has since included non-administrators) which occurs every three months to determine whether or not promoted users should remain in their position. This may seem radical, but it is to ensure that only qualified members keep their rights.

Under the "Discussion" heading, we will discuss whether the user is fit for their position(s). When voting, you are encouraged to add a reason why you want someone demoted or why they should keep their rights. If a user has a majority of all participants and participating administrators (more than 50%) supporting the removal of their position (neutrals excluded), they may be subject to demotion. Bureaucrats will determine the final verdict, but the community discussion will be taken very largely into account. This is to avoid "friend" and "grudge" voting.

Please keep this discussion civil and don't be insulting. If you have criticism, make it constructive. If you are one of the users being reviewed, please do not force others to support you. Calmly responding to a user's concern is fine, but aggressive behavior will be taken into account by the bureaucrats when reviewing the results.

Voting key:

• {{Keep}} - if you believe the user should keep their rights.
• {{Neutral}} - if you are neutral to the user keeping their rights.
• {{Suspend}} - if you believe the user should be suspended. Be sure to state your proposed length.
• {{Remove}} - if you believe the user should lose their rights.

Obviously, you may not support yourself.

This discussion will end on Saturday, November 24, 2018 at 8:50 a.m., eastern time. --Spongebob456 ^talk 13:51, November 10, 2018 (UTC)

Discussion

Golfpecks256

• Keep - TheKorraFanatic ^{(Talk Page) (Contributions) (Guestbook)}
• Strong Keep - --CheeseCrocker (talk) 18:46, October 13, 2018 (UTC)
• Keep -  FireMatch ^(W•C•E)   
• Keep -  Anthony2306 ^{(W•C•L•E)}  15:07, November 10, 2018 (UTC) 
• Keep - Expert at
• Keep -  Figmeister ^(W•C•E)  17:01, November 10, 2018 (UTC) 
• Extremely Strong Keep -  A Wikia Contributor ITALIAN's return ^(M•C•E)  ​​​​​
• Remove - While this user has shown some growth I do feel like his immaturity off-wiki seems to hold up, and while many may state an argument on how "off-wiki matters do not matter", there have been many off-wiki matters dealt on this wiki, especially with Discord. I do feel like spending more time as an assistant will help fill in these gaps, as I feel like there could have been more to have been done as an assistant.  Rocky Lobster ^(M•C•E)

• Comment - Thank you for your concern and I am sorry you feel this way. Were there any specific areas off-wiki were my maturity has been an issue? Also, I'm curious if you might be referring to my maturity quite some time ago or not. As if it might be my previous history in relation with you and some others, perhaps I might've improved from that in terms of being mature everywhere? If not, that's something I'll consider. (Contact • Contrib) 18:07, November 10, 2018 (UTC)

• Remove - Per Rocky.  Chuck123456 ^(M•C•E)  17:34, November 10, 2018 (UTC) 
• Weak Keep -
• {{Remove} Per Rocky --♬ We are the good guys ♬ (talk) 18:41, November 10, 2018 (UTC)
• Keep - I kinda feel that golf is the most reliable and convenient admin. He's also helpful. I think his previous interaction should be left behind as he's been doing a good job so far here as admin. Correct me if I'm wrong. -1033Forest (talk) 18:46, November 10, 2018 (UTC)
• Remove - Sorry man, but Rocky has some good points.  DanzxvFan8275 (M•C•U•E)  19:30, November 10, 2018 (UTC) 

Alex.sapre

• Strong Keep - TheKorraFanatic ^{(Talk Page) (Contributions) (Guestbook)}
• Keep - --CheeseCrocker (talk) 18:46, October 13, 2018 (UTC)
• Keep -  Anthony2306 ^{(W•C•L•E)}  15:07, November 10, 2018 (UTC) 
• Neutral - Not as active as the other admins. Expert at
• Keep -  Figmeister ^(W•C•E)  17:01, November 10, 2018 (UTC) 
• Neutral -  FireMatch ^(W•C•E) 
• Keep -  A Wikia Contributor ITALIAN's return ^(M•C•E)  ​​​​​
• Strong Keep - The gamer 987654321 (M.W. B. C.) who forgot to put their signature? i did!
• Keep - (Contact • Contrib) 18:15, November 10, 2018 (UTC)
• Keep - --♬ We are the good guys ♬ (talk) 18:41, November 10, 2018 (UTC)
• Neutral - I don't know how good this guy is with admin so I'll be at neutral. -1033Forest (talk) 19:36, November 10, 2018 (UTC)

Jackninja5DipperGravityFalls

• Keep - TheKorraFanatic ^{(Talk Page) (Contributions) (Guestbook)}
• Neutral - Haven't really seen much of him/her, so idk. --CheeseCrocker (talk) 18:46, October 13, 2018 (UTC)
• Keep -  Anthony2306 ^{(W•C•L•E)}  15:07, November 10, 2018 (UTC) 
• Remove - Goes on wikibreak too much nowadays; doesn't do much anymore. Expert at
• Keep -  Figmeister ^(W•C•E)  17:01, November 10, 2018 (UTC) 
• Remove - Doesn't really do much from what I've seen.  FireMatch ^(W•C•E) 
• Weak Keep -  A Wikia Contributor ITALIAN's return ^(M•C•E)  ​​​​
• Keep - I would have thought that a wikibreak would be an acceptable reason to take a break from a wiki. - The gamer 987654321 (M.W. B. C.) 18:08, November 10, 2018 (UTC)
• Keep - (Contact • Contrib) 18:15, November 10, 2018 (UTC)
• Neutral - --♬ We are the good guys ♬ (talk) 18:37, November 10, 2018 (UTC)
• Extremely Strong Remove - You literally violated the wikibreak rule of taking more than three valid wikibreaks in a year. You still barely edit. You don't even use admin at all too. -1033Forest (talk) 19:36, November 10, 2018 (UTC)

Assistants

DragonSpore18

• Strong Keep - TheKorraFanatic ^{(Talk Page) (Contributions) (Guestbook)}
• Keep - --CheeseCrocker (talk) 18:46, October 13, 2018 (UTC)
• Keep -  Anthony2306 ^{(W•C•L•E)}  15:07, November 10, 2018 (UTC) 
• Keep - Expert at
• Keep -  Figmeister ^(W•C•E)  17:01, November 10, 2018 (UTC) 
• Strong Keep -  FireMatch ^(W•C•E) 
• Extremely Strong Keep -  A Wikia Contributor ITALIAN's return ^(M•C•E)  ​​​​
• Neutral - The gamer 987654321 (M.W. B. C.) 18:08, November 10, 2018 (UTC)
• Keep - (Contact • Contrib) 18:13, November 10, 2018 (UTC)
• Keep - Sure. -1033Forest (talk) 19:36, November 10, 2018 (UTC)

The Smarter, Wiser King Dedede

• Neutral - TheKorraFanatic ^{(Talk Page) (Contributions) (Guestbook)}
• Keep - --CheeseCrocker (talk) 18:46, October 13, 2018 (UTC)
• Keep -  Anthony2306 ^{(W•C•L•E)}  15:07, November 10, 2018 (UTC) 
• Weak Keep - Expert at
• Keep -  Figmeister ^(W•C•E)  17:01, November 10, 2018 (UTC) 
• Neutral -  FireMatch ^(W•C•E) 
• Strong Keep -  A Wikia Contributor ITALIAN's return ^(M•C•E)  ​​​​
• Keep? - The gamer 987654321 (M.W. B. C.) 18:08, November 10, 2018 (UTC)
• Keep - (Contact • Contrib) 18:13, November 10, 2018 (UTC)
• Neutral - -1033Forest (talk) 19:36, November 10, 2018 (UTC)

Anthony2306

• Keep - TheKorraFanatic ^{(Talk Page) (Contributions) (Guestbook)}
• Strong Keep - --CheeseCrocker (talk) 18:46, October 13, 2018 (UTC)
• Keep - Expert at
• Strong Keep -  Figmeister ^(W•C•E)  17:01, November 10, 2018 (UTC) 
• Extremely Strong Keep -  FireMatch ^(W•C•E) 
• Extremely Strong Keep -  A Wikia Contributor ITALIAN's return ^(M•C•E)  ​​​​
• Neutral - The gamer 987654321 (M.W. B. C.) 18:08, November 10, 2018 (UTC)
• Keep - (Contact • Contrib) 18:13, November 10, 2018 (UTC)

Then for Anthony2306:

• Keep - Looks like he works hard. -1033Forest (talk) 19:36, November 10, 2018 (UTC)

Discussion moderators

CheeseCrocker

• Keep - TheKorraFanatic ^{(Talk Page) (Contributions) (Guestbook)}
• Keep -  Anthony2306 ^{(W•C•L•E)}  15:07, November 10, 2018 (UTC) 
• Weak Keep - Does a good job as a discussion mod. The only reason why I'm giving it weak is because he resently got a notice on his wall be an admin. Otherwise, I vote Keep. Expert at
• Keep -  Figmeister ^(W•C•E)  17:01, November 10, 2018 (UTC) 
• Keep -  FireMatch ^(W•C•E) 
• Extremely Strong Keep -  A Wikia Contributor ITALIAN's return ^(M•C•E)  ​​​​
• Keep - Edits always show good intentions even when they are not as they should be (read: Thread:698422 is not a reasonable concern) - The gamer 987654321 (M.W. B. C.) 18:19, November 10, 2018 (UTC)
• Keep - I don't think a simple mistake he's been doing means he gets demoted-1033Forest (talk) 19:36, November 10, 2018 (UTC)

Qwertyxp2000 the second

• Neutral - TheKorraFanatic ^{(Talk Page) (Contributions) (Guestbook)}
• Neutral - Not very active --CheeseCrocker (talk) 18:46, October 13, 2018 (UTC)
• Neutral -  Anthony2306 ^{(W•C•L•E)}  15:07, November 10, 2018 (UTC) 
• Remove - I've wanted this guy removed for a long time. Does absolutely nothing anymore. Last 50 edits go back to September. Expert at
• Remove - Not very active anymore.  Figmeister ^(W•C•E)  17:01, November 10, 2018 (UTC) 
• Remove - Per Expert and Figmeister.  FireMatch ^(W•C•E) 
• Weak Remove -  A Wikia Contributor ITALIAN's return ^(M•C•E)  ​​​​
• Remove - Inconsistent activity. I also did not like how he reacted to previous criticism against him on previous reviews. He also rarely uses his rights.
  (Contact • Contrib) 18:12, November 10, 2018 (UTC)
• Remove - I am not normally one to encourage demotion due to inactivity, but the few edits that he does make are predominantly not main namespace. Per to what User:Expert at Terraria said, I have wanted this user to be removed for a long time, but for reasons I am not sure are still present. - The gamer 987654321 (M.W. B. C.) 18:19, November 10, 2018 (UTC)
• Extremely Strong Remove - If he doesn't use his rights, then why is he still discussion mod?? -1033Forest (talk) 19:36, November 10, 2018 (UTC)

Anthony2306

• Keep - TheKorraFanatic ^{(Talk Page) (Contributions) (Guestbook)}
• Keep - --CheeseCrocker (talk) 18:46, October 13, 2018 (UTC)
• Keep - Expert at
• Keep -  Figmeister ^(W•C•E)  17:01, November 10, 2018 (UTC) 
• Keep -  FireMatch ^(W•C•E) 
• Extremely Strong Keep -  A Wikia Contributor ITALIAN's return ^(M•C•E)  ​​​​
• Neutral - The gamer 987654321 (M.W. B. C.) 18:23, November 10, 2018 (UTC)
• Keep - -1033Forest (talk) 19:36, November 10, 2018 (UTC)

Chat moderators

TheKorraFanatic

• Keep -  Anthony2306 ^{(W•C•L•E)}  15:07, November 10, 2018 (UTC) 
• Weak Keep - Expert at
• Keep -  Figmeister ^(W•C•E)  17:01, November 10, 2018 (UTC) 
• Strong Keep -  A Wikia Contributor ITALIAN's return ^(M•C•E)  ​​​
• Keep - (Contact • Contrib) 18:10, November 10, 2018 (UTC)
• Neutral - The gamer 987654321 (M.W. B. C.) 18:23, November 10, 2018 (UTC)
• Keep - Active enough. -1033Forest (talk) 19:36, November 10, 2018 (UTC)

Auron~Guardian

• Keep - TheKorraFanatic ^{(Talk Page) (Contributions) (Guestbook)}
• Keep -  Anthony2306 ^{(W•C•L•E)}  15:07, November 10, 2018 (UTC) 
• Remove - Inactive. I'm not sure if he's active on chat, but he has to be active on the wiki as well, which he's definitely not; hasn't edited since July. Expert at
• Remove - Per Expert FireMatch ^(W•C•E) 
• Neutral -  Figmeister ^(W•C•E)  17:01, November 10, 2018 (UTC) 
• Extremely Strong Remove -  A Wikia Contributor ITALIAN's return ^(M•C•E)  ​​​
• Keep - Auron is active on chat. He does make some appearances throughout the week. Usually, when no other moderators are on. (Contact • Contrib) 18:10, November 10, 2018 (UTC)
• Keep - Lack of edits from a chat moderator does not necessarily demand removal. - The gamer 987654321 (M.W. B. C.) 18:23, November 10, 2018 (UTC)
• Remove - Chat mods aren't only supposed to make sure chat is good but also show they are interested in this wiki by editing. -1033Forest (talk) 19:36, November 10, 2018 (UTC)