Encyclopedia SpongeBobia
Don't have an account?
Register
Register
Encyclopedia SpongeBobia
Encyclopedia SpongeBobia
15,595
pages
in: Archives, Community

Changes: ESB:Suggestions

Back to page
View source
No edit summary
m (Protected "ESB:Suggestions" (‎[edit=sysop] (indefinite) ‎[move=sysop] (indefinite)))
(38 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
  +
{{Archived}}
 
{{Structure}}
  
{{Structure}}
  +
Welcome to the '''suggestions''' page. At [[Encyclopedia SpongeBobia|ESB]], everyone's ideas are welcome and considered. Post your ideas on the designated threads and your suggestion will be brought up at one of the meetings and discussed. This page lists all such suggestions and their status.
−
This page lists all suggestions.
  
   
  +
<!--
−
{| class="wikitable" border="1"
  
  +
{{S-list
  +
|number =
  +
|user =
  +
|status =
  +
|status-details =
  +
|suggestion =
  +
}}
  +
-->
  +
  +
{| class="wikitable" border="1" width="470px"
 
! #
  
! #
  +
! User
−
! Suggestion
  
 
! Status
  
! Status
 
|-
  
|-
−
|colspan="3" align="center"|'''UPDATED JUNE 9, 2014'''
 +
|colspan="3" align="center"|'''UPDATED SEPTEMBER 21, 2014'''
 
|-
  
|-
−
|colspan="3" align="center"|'''Part I'''
 +
|colspan="3" align="center"|'''[[Thread:101998|Part I]]'''
  +
{{S-list
  +
|number = 1
  +
|user = Lemony gemmy
  +
|status = [[File:Support.png|15px]]
  +
|status-details = Accepted.
  +
|suggestion = More background contests.
  +
}}
  +
{{S-list
  +
|number = 2
  +
|user = Koolkitty108
  +
|status = [[File:Oppose.png|15px]]
  +
|status-details = Too complex
  +
|suggestion = Slide show alongside galleries.
  +
}}
  +
{{S-list
  +
|number = 3
  +
|user = JCM
  +
|status = [[File:Support.png|15px]]
  +
|status-details = '''PASSED''' ([[ESB:Discussions/Main Page Redesign (2014)|see archive]])
  +
|suggestion = Main page redesign.
  +
}}
  +
{{S-list
  +
|number = 4
  +
|user = 120d
  +
|status = [[File:Support.png|15px]]
  +
|status-details = '''PASSED''' ([[ESB:Discussions/Redirects for usernames|see archive]])
  +
|suggestion = May 3, 2014 - Redirects for usernames.
  +
}}
  +
{{S-list
  +
|number = 5
  +
|user = 120d
  +
|status = [[File:Oppose.png|15px]]
  +
|status-details = Technical issues
  +
|suggestion = May 3, 2014 - All info boxes with set image sizes.
  +
}}
  +
{{S-list
  +
|number = 6
  +
|user = Carkle100
  +
|status = [[File:Neutral.png|15px]]
  +
|status-details = Pending completion
  +
|suggestion = May 3, 2014 - Wiki history in navigation
  +
}}
  +
{{S-list
  +
|number = 7
  +
|user = Timjames98
  +
|status = [[File:Support.png|15px]]
  +
|status-details = '''PASSED''' ([[ESB:Discussions/Character guidelines|see archive]])
  +
|suggestion = May 3, 2014 - Minor characters with their own pages.
  +
}}
  +
{{S-list
  +
|number = 8
  +
|user = 120d
  +
|status = [[File:Neutral.png|15px]]
  +
|status-details = Pending creation.
  +
|suggestion = May 4, 2014 - User tutorial
  +
}}
  +
{{S-list
  +
|number = 9
  +
|user = Spongebob456
  +
|status = [[File:Support.png|15px]]
  +
|status-details = '''PASSED''' ([[ESB:Discussions/User of the Month|see archive]])
  +
|suggestion = May 4, 2014 - Awards (such as user of the month)
  +
}}
  +
{{S-list
  +
|number = 10
  +
|user = Spongebob456
  +
|status = [[File:Support.png|15px]]
  +
|status-details = '''PASSED''' ([[ESB:Discussions/Article of the Month|see archive]])
  +
|suggestion = May 4, 2014 - Article of the month
  +
}}
  +
{{S-list
  +
|number = 11
  +
|user = Ssj4gogita4
  +
|status = [[File:Oppose.png|15px]]
  +
|status-details = '''DISMISSED'''
  +
|suggestion = May 4, 2014 - Redesign the entire wiki.
  +
}}
 
|-
  
|-
  +
|colspan="3" align="center"|'''[[Thread:103171|Part II]]'''
−
|1
  
  +
{{S-list
−
|More background contests
  
  +
|number = 12
−
|[[File:Support.png|15px]] We will continue to have background contests.
  
  +
|user = Muchacha
  +
|status = [[File:Neutral.png|15px]]
  +
|status-details = Postponed.
  +
|suggestion = May 5, 2014 - Episode reviews and analysis
  +
}}
  +
{{S-list
  +
|number = 13
  +
|user = 120d
  +
|status = [[File:Support.png|15px]]
  +
|status-details = Bot run complete.
  +
|suggestion = May 11, 2014 - Replace </references> with <nowiki>{{Reflist}}</nowiki>
  +
}}
  +
{{S-list
  +
|number = 14
  +
|user = SpongeyTube
  +
|status = {{-}}
  +
|status-details = '''DISMISSED'''
  +
|suggestion = May 11, 2014 - Auto Refresh Wiki Activity <!--(like at Uncle Grandpa Wiki)-->
  +
}}
  +
{{S-list
  +
|number = 15
  +
|user = 120d
  +
|status = {{-}}
  +
|status-details = '''DISMISSED'''
  +
|suggestion = May 17, 2014 - Eliminate moral/legal issues listed in articles.
  +
}}
 
|-
  
|-
  +
|colspan="3" align="center"|'''[[Thread:105895|Part III]]'''
−
|2
  
  +
{{S-list
−
|Slide show alongside galleries.
  
  +
|number = 16
−
|[[File:Oppose.png|15px]] Slide shows are a little too much for the complex galleries we already have.
  
  +
|user = 120d
  +
|status = [[File:Oppose.png|15px]]
  +
|status-details = '''DISMISSED'''
  +
|suggestion = May 19, 2014 - Changing of proposal times.
  +
}}
  +
{{S-list
  +
|number = 17
  +
|user = Lemony gemmy
  +
|status = [[File:Oppose.png|15px]]
  +
|status-details = No specified alternative.
  +
|suggestion = May 19, 2014 - Change of yellow in theme.
  +
}}
  +
{{S-list
  +
|number = 18
  +
|user = Muchacha
  +
|status = [[File:Oppose.png|15px]]
  +
|status-details = "Teams" never really worked before; efforts are being made to eliminate stubs.
  +
|suggestion = May 20, 2014 - Cleanup team to eliminate stubs.
  +
}}
  +
{{S-list
  +
|number = 19
  +
|user = 120d
  +
|status = [[File:Support.png|15px]]
  +
|status-details = '''ACCEPTED'''
  +
|suggestion = May 20, 2014 - Crossover characters list
  +
}}
  +
{{S-list
  +
|number = 20
  +
|user = 120d
  +
|status = [[File:Oppose.png|15px]]
  +
|status-details = '''DISMISSED'''
  +
|suggestion = May 21, 2014 - Defining cultural references.
  +
}}
  +
{{S-list
  +
|number = 21
  +
|user = AW10
  +
|status = [[File:Oppose.png|15px]] ([[ESB:Discussions/Infobox color scheme|see archive]])
  +
|status-details = '''CANCELLED'''
  +
|suggestion = May 21, 2014 - Changing infobox colors.
  +
}}
  +
{{S-list
  +
|number = 22
  +
|user = 120d
  +
|status = [[File:Neutral.png|15px]]
  +
|status-details = Pending discussion.
  +
|suggestion = May 25, 2014 - Using SBM ratings in reception.
  +
}}
  +
{{S-list
  +
|number = 23
  +
|user = AW10
  +
|status = [[File:Support.png|15px]]
  +
|status-details = Implemented.
  +
|suggestion = May 25, 2014 - Remove text-align:justify.
  +
}}
 
|-
  
|-
  +
|colspan="3" align="center"|'''Part IV''' (May 26, 2014)
−
|3
  
  +
{{S-list
−
|Main page redesign.
  
  +
|number = 24
−
|[[File:Support.png|15px]] '''PASSED''' ([[ESB:Discussions/Main Page Redesign (2014)|see archive]])
  
  +
|user = Muchacha
  +
|status = [[File:Oppose.png|15px]]
  +
|status-details = Rejected.
  +
|suggestion = May 28, 2014 - Restore article comments.
  +
}}
  +
{{S-list
  +
|number = 25
  +
|user = Greatlegoman29
  +
|status = [[File:Neutral.png|15px]]
  +
|status-details = Pending ideas.
  +
|suggestion = May 28, 2014 - Rebuild [[SpongeBob SquarePants (series)]] article.
  +
}}
  +
{{S-list
  +
|number = 26
  +
|user = 120d
  +
|status = [[File:Oppose.png|15px]]
  +
|status-details = '''REJECTED:''' ([[ESB:Discussions/Content limits for people articles|see archive]])
  +
|suggestion = June 4, 2014 - Downsizing filmography lists on people articles.
  +
}}
  +
{{S-list
  +
|number = 27
  +
|user = 120d
  +
|status = [[File:Oppose.png|15px]]
  +
|status-details = '''REJECTED'''
  +
|suggestion = June 4, 2014 - Adding a discussion notification on main page.
  +
}}
  +
{{S-list
  +
|number = 28
  +
|user = Muchacha
  +
|status = [[File:Support.png|15px]]
  +
|status-details = '''ACCEPTED'''
  +
|suggestion = June 8, 2014 - Using photos in synopsis sections.
  +
}}
  +
{{S-list
  +
|number = 29
  +
|user = Muchacha
  +
|status = [[File:Neutral.png|15px]]
  +
|status-details = Pending discussion.
  +
|suggestion = June 8, 2014 - Returning quote sections to episode articles.
  +
}}
  +
{{S-list
  +
|number = 30
  +
|user = Muchacha
  +
|status = [[File:Oppose.png|15px]]
  +
|status-details = '''DISMISSED'''
  +
|suggestion = June 8, 2014 - Separate trivia and errors to another page.
  +
}}
  +
{{S-list
  +
|number = 31
  +
|user = 120d
  +
|status = [[File:Oppose.png|15px]]
  +
|status-details = '''REJECTED''' ([[ESB:Discussions/SpongeBob memes|see archive]])
  +
|suggestion = June 8, 2014 - Separate [[SpongeBob SquarePants internet phenomena]] into tabs.
  +
}}
 
|-
  
|-
  +
|colspan="4" align="center"|'''[[Thread:110200|Part V]]'''
−
|4
  
−
|Redirects for usernames.
  
−
|[[File:Support.png|15px]] '''PASSED''' ([[ESB:Discussions/Redirects for usernames|see archive]])
  
 
|-
  
|-
−
|5
 +
|32
  +
|Aliases in their own section
−
|All info boxes with set image sizes.
  
  +
|
−
|[[File:Oppose.png|15px]] This cannot be done because it would cause infoboxes to be wider for certain pages.
  
  +
|[[File:Support.png|15px]] Accepted
 
|-
  
|-
−
|6
 +
|33
  +
|Use of discussion formatting as AW10 has done at FSB
−
|Minor characters with their own pages.
  
  +
|
−
|[[File:Support.png|15px]] '''PASSED''' ([[ESB:Discussions/Character guidelines|see archive]])
  
  +
|[[File:Support.png|15px]] Impletmented
 
|-
  
|-
−
|7
 +
|34
  +
|Changing User to "Employee" of the Month
−
|Wiki history in navigation
  
−
|[[File:Neutral.png|15px]] Wiki history must be completed (or at least mostly) first
 +
|[[File:Oppose.png|15px]] Dismissed
 
|-
  
|-
−
|8
 +
|35
  +
|Poll of the week
−
|User tutorial.
  
  +
|
−
|[[File:Neutral.png|15px]] There is currently several projects going on, but anyone is welcome to start working on a tutorial.
  
  +
|[[File:Support.png|15px]] Accepted.
 
|-
  
|-
−
|9
 +
|36
  +
|Changing the time limit between admin requests
−
|Awards (such as user of the month)
  
  +
|
−
|[[File:Support.png|15px]] '''PASSED''' ([[ESB:Discussions/User of the Month|see archive]])
  
  +
|[[File:Oppose.png|15px]] Dismissed.
 
|-
  
|-
−
|10
 +
|37
  +
|Automatic deleting system
−
|Article of the month
  
  +
|
−
|[[File:Support.png|15px]] '''PASSED''' ([[ESB:Discussions/Article of the Month|see archive]])
  
  +
|[[File:Oppose.png|15px]] Dismissed.
 
|-
  
|-
−
|11
 +
|38
  +
|Stub length
−
|Redesign the entire wiki.
  
  +
|
−
|[[File:Oppose.png|15px]] We would need specific suggestions for this one. Not just a general suggestion.
  
  +
|[[File:Support.png|15px]] '''1,000 bytes''' ([[ESB:Discussions/Stub length|see archive]])
 
|-
  
|-
  +
|39
−
|colspan="3" align="center"|'''Part II'''
  
  +
|Require edit summaries
  +
|
  +
|[[File:Oppose.png|15px]] Dismissed.
 
|-
  
|-
−
|12
 +
|40
−
|Episode reviews and analysis
 +
|Episode ratings on articles
  +
|
−
|[[File:Neutral.png|15px]] Too much going on at the moment to consider. Perhaps later.
  
  +
|[[File:Neutral.png|15px]] Pending ideas.
 
|-
  
|-
−
|13
 +
|41
  +
|Italicize vs. Quoting episode titles
−
|Replace </references> with <nowiki>{{Reflist}}</nowiki>
  
  +
|
−
|[[File:Support.png|15px]] Bot run complete. If anything is missed, make the change manually.
  
  +
|[[File:Support.png|15px]] '''Quoting''' ([[ESB:Discussions/Quote or Italicize episode titles|see archive]])
 
|-
  
|-
−
|14
 +
|42
  +
|Subgalleries project
−
|Auto Refresh Wiki Activity <!--(like at Uncle Grandpa Wiki)-->
  
  +
|
−
|[[File:Oppose.png|15px]] There is a glitch in doing this.
  
  +
|[[File:Support.png|15px]] A project page can be created.
 
|-
  
|-
−
|15
 +
|43
  +
|Fact limits on ___ time that ___ happened. <!--Once a fact that is "this is the ___ time that _____", has reached 11 times, I think it can no longer be a fact like that and should be removed because by that point it does not become rare enough to point it out.-->
−
|Eliminate moral/legal issues listed in articles.
  
  +
|
−
|[[File:Neutral.png|15px]] Pending administrative discussion
  
  +
|[[File:Oppose.png|15px]] Dismissed.
 
|-
  
|-
  +
|44
−
|colspan="3" align="center"|'''Part III'''
  
  +
|Delayed administrative participation in discussions
  +
|
  +
|[[File:Oppose.png|15px]] '''REJECTED:''' ([[ESB:Discussions/Delayed admin involvement in discussions|see archive]])
 
|-
  
|-
−
|16
 +
|45
  +
|Restore character pages from redirects
−
|Changing of proposal times
  
  +
|
−
|[[File:Oppose.png|15px]] Not necessary to change.
  
  +
|[[File:Support.png|15px]] Accepted and encouraged
 
|-
  
|-
  +
|colspan="3" align="center"|'''[[Thread:115232|Part VI]]'''
−
|17
  
−
|Change of yellow in theme
  
−
|[[File:Oppose.png|15px]] No specified alternative.
  
 
|-
  
|-
−
|18
 +
|46
  +
|Viewership in lists
−
|Cleanup team to eliminate stubs
  
  +
|
−
|[[File:Neutral.png|15px]] "Teams" never really worked before; efforts are being made to eliminate stubs.
  
  +
|[[File:Neutral.png|15px]] Pending implementation.
 
|-
  
|-
−
|19
 +
|47
  +
|Rollback requests
−
|Crossover characters list
  
  +
|
−
|[[File:Support.png|15px]] No discussion necessary
  
  +
|[[File:Oppose.png|15px]] Dismissed.
 
|-
  
|-
−
|20
 +
|48
  +
|Display clock
−
|Defining cultural references
  
  +
|
−
|[[File:Neutral.png|15px]] '''CURRENT DISCUSSION:''' [[Thread:107392]]
  
  +
|[[File:Support.png|15px]] Accepted.
 
|-
  
|-
−
|21
 +
|49
  +
|Voice output
−
|Changing infobox colors
  
  +
|
−
|[[File:Oppose.png|15px]] '''CANCELLED''' ([[ESB:Discussions/Infobox color scheme|see archive]])
  
  +
|[[File:Oppose.png|15px]] '''REJECTED:''' ([[ESB:Discussions/Voice output|see archive]])
 
|-
  
|-
−
|22
 +
|50
  +
|Trivia quizzes
−
|Using SBM ratings in reception
  
  +
|
−
|[[File:Neutral.png|15px]] Pending further discussion
  
  +
|[[File:Support.png|15px]] Accepted.
 
|-
  
|-
−
|23
 +
|51
  +
|BackToTopArrow
−
|Remove text-align:justify
  
  +
|
−
|[[File:Support.png|15px]] Implemented.
  
  +
|[[File:Support.png|15px]] '''PASSED:''' ([[ESB:Discussions/BackToTopArrow|see archive]])
 
|-
  
|-
  +
|52
−
|colspan="3" align="center"|'''Part IV'''
  
  +
|Changing terminology for signed in/not signed users
  +
|
  +
|[[File:Oppose.png|15px]] Dismissed.
 
|-
  
|-
−
|24
 +
|53
  +
|Character hover designs
−
|Restore article comments
  
  +
|
−
|[[File:Oppose.png|15px]] Rejected.
  
  +
|[[File:Support.png|15px]] '''PASSED:''' ([[ESB:Discussions/Character hover design|see archive]])
 
|-
  
|-
−
|25
 +
|54
  +
|"Episodes that focus on <nowiki><character></nowiki>" categories
−
|Rebuild [[SpongeBob SquarePants (series)]] article
  
  +
|
−
|[[File:Neutral.png|15px]] Pending ideas.
  
  +
|[[File:Oppose.png|15px]] Dismissed.
 
|-
  
|-
−
|26
 +
|55
  +
|Require people to give reason for their options in discussions
−
|Downsizing filmography lists on people articles
  
  +
|
−
|[[File:Neutral.png|15px]] Pending discussion.
  
  +
|[[File:Oppose.png|15px]] Dismissed.
 
|-
  
|-
−
|27
 +
|56
  +
|All images in one category
−
|Adding a discussion notification on main page.
  
  +
|
−
|[[File:Neutral.png|15px]] Pending discussion.
  
  +
|[[File:Oppose.png|15px]] Dismissed.
 
|-
  
|-
−
|28
 +
|57
  +
|Galleryheadings on appearance articles
−
|Using photos in synopsis sections.
  
  +
|
−
|[[File:Neutral.png|15px]] Pending discussion.
  
  +
|[[File:Oppose.png|15px]] Dismissed.
 
|-
  
|-
−
|29
 +
|58
  +
|Separate TV movies from episodes
−
|Returning quote sections to episode articles.
  
  +
|
−
|[[File:Neutral.png|15px]] Pending discussion.
  
  +
|[[File:Oppose.png|15px]] Dismissed.
 
|-
  
|-
−
|30
 +
|59
  +
|OTab
−
|Separate trivia and errors to another page.
  
  +
|
  +
|[[File:Oppose.png|15px]] '''REJECTED:''' ([[ESB:Discussions/OTab|see archive]])
  +
|-
  +
|60
  +
|More usertags
  +
|
  +
|[[File:Support.png|15px]] Accepted.
  +
|-
  +
|61
  +
|Season navigation templates
  +
|
  +
|[[File:Oppose.png|15px]] Dismissed.
  +
|-
  +
|62
  +
|Change rating system to go along with the additional "Strong Support," "Weak Support," etc.
  +
|
  +
|[[File:Oppose.png|15px]] Dismissed.
  +
|-
  +
|63
  +
|Add iTunes release date and link to "release" section.
  +
|
  +
|[[File:Support.png|15px]] Accepted.
  +
|-
  +
|64
  +
|Custom cursors
  +
|
  +
|[[File:Oppose.png|15px]] Dismissed.
  +
|-
  +
|65
  +
|ReferencePopups
  +
|
  +
|[[File:Support.png|15px]] Accepted.
  +
|-
  +
|66
  +
|"Tournaments" on certain topics (best episode, etc.)
  +
|
 
|[[File:Neutral.png|15px]] Pending discussion.
  
|[[File:Neutral.png|15px]] Pending discussion.
 
|-
  
|-
−
|31
 +
|67
  +
|Change sides of entire site
−
|Separate [[SpongeBob SquarePants internet phenomena]] into tabs.
  
  +
|
−
|[[File:Neutral.png|15px]] Another project to this regard is pending; pending staff meeting discussion.
  
  +
|[[File:Support.png|15px]] '''PASSED:''' ([[ESB:Discussions/New background sides|see archive]])
 
|-
  
|-
−
|colspan="3" align="center"|'''Part V'''
 +
|colspan="3" align="center"|'''[[Thread:117558|Part VII]]'''
 
|-
  
|-
  +
|68
−
|colspan="3" align="center"|[[Thread:110200|Click here to make suggestions]]
  
  +
|Day/night chat
  +
|
  +
|[[File:Oppose.png|15px]] Dismissed.
 
|-
  
|-
−
|32
 +
|69
  +
|AutoEditDropdown
−
|Aliases in their own section
  
  +
|
  +
|[[File:Oppose.png|15px]] Dismissed.
  +
|-
  +
|70
  +
|ImageAnnotator
  +
|
  +
|[[File:Oppose.png|15px]] Dismissed.
  +
|-
  +
|71
  +
|FileUsageAuto-update
  +
|
  +
|[[File:Oppose.png|15px]] Dismissed.
  +
|-
  +
|72
  +
|DynamicImages
  +
|
  +
|[[File:Neutral.png|15px]] Pending implementation
  +
|-
  +
|73
  +
|FloatingToc
  +
|
  +
|[[File:Neutral.png|15px]] Pending implementation
  +
|-
  +
|74
  +
|CGI video on main page
  +
|
  +
|[[File:Oppose.png|15px]] Dismissed.
  +
|-
  +
|75
  +
|MiniComplete
  +
|
  +
|[[File:Neutral.png|15px]] Pending implementation
  +
|-
  +
|76
  +
|Places listing on episode articles
  +
|
  +
|[[File:Oppose.png|15px]] Dismissed.
  +
|-
  +
|77
  +
|Appearance tables for locations
  +
|
  +
|[[File:Support.png|15px]] Accepted.
  +
|-
  +
|78
  +
|Tables for character appearance totals
  +
|
  +
|[[File:Neutral.png|15px]] Save for future.
  +
|-
  +
|79
  +
|Episode disambiguations (episode)
  +
|
  +
|[[File:Oppose.png|15px]] Dismissed.
  +
|-
  +
|80
  +
|Separated character templates
  +
|
  +
|[[File:Neutral.png|15px]] Dismissed for another idea (bottom episode templates)
  +
|-
  +
|81
  +
|Pages for the pirates from the movie
  +
|
  +
|[[File:Support.png|15px]] Single page accepted.
  +
|-
  +
|82
  +
|Film trailer on main page.
  +
|
  +
|[[File:Oppose.png|15px]] Dismissed.
  +
|-
  +
|83
  +
|Puncuation list
  +
|
  +
|[[File:Support.png|15px]] Accepted.
  +
|-
  +
|84
  +
|Image categories for episodes
  +
|
  +
|[[File:Support.png|15px]] Accepted.
  +
|-
  +
|85
  +
|"I think we shouldn't allow any general reception of episodes. I think it should all be sourced and about certain reviewers."
  +
|
 
|[[File:Neutral.png|15px]] Pending discussion
  
|[[File:Neutral.png|15px]] Pending discussion
 
|-
  
|-
−
|33
 +
|86
  +
|Adopt 3 revert rule from Wikipedia
−
|Use of discussion formatting as AW10 has done at FSB
  
  +
|
 
|[[File:Neutral.png|15px]] Pending discussion
  
|[[File:Neutral.png|15px]] Pending discussion
 
|-
  
|-
−
|34
 +
|87
  +
|Slogan change
−
|Changing User to "Employee" of the Month
  
  +
|
−
|[[File:Oppose.png|15px]] Dismissed
  
  +
|[[File:Support.png|15px]] Accepted.
 
|-
  
|-
−
|35
 +
|88
  +
|Requests for block page (or change ban to block, or change to abuse report)
−
|Poll of the week
  
  +
|
  +
|[[File:Neutral.png|15px]] Pending implementation.
  +
|-
  +
|89
  +
|Show/hide for templates on bottom of page.
  +
|
  +
|[[File:Neutral.png|15px]] Pending implementation.
  +
|-
  +
|90
  +
|"Episode galleries should be reordered and named sequentially."
  +
|
  +
|[[File:Support.png|15px]] Accepted.
  +
|-
  +
|91
  +
|"In addition to this, all episode errors should be listed in the order they appear for that episode."
  +
|
  +
|[[File:Oppose.png|15px]] Dismissed.
  +
|-
  +
|92
  +
|"How about we organize all tabs on List of characters like it is organized for List of merchandise/videos?"
  +
|
 
|[[File:Neutral.png|15px]] Pending discussion
  
|[[File:Neutral.png|15px]] Pending discussion
 
|-
  
|-
−
|36
 +
|93
  +
|"I also suggest we create a rule that on message walls, discussion boards, forums and everywhere same system is used, if you want to quote somone, never do a double quote, only qoute the message you are replying to."
−
|Changing the time limit between admin requests
  
  +
|
 
|[[File:Neutral.png|15px]] Pending discussion
  
|[[File:Neutral.png|15px]] Pending discussion
 
|-
  
|-
−
|37
 +
|94
  +
|Updating the "Multiple Accounts" policy.
−
|Automatic deleting system
  
  +
|
−
|[[File:Oppose.png|15px]] Dismissed
  
  +
|[[File:Neutral.png|15px]] Pending discussion
 
|-
  
|-
−
|38
 +
|95
  +
|Link spongebobia.wikia.com at www.spongebobia.com
−
|Stub length
  
  +
|
−
|[[File:Neutral.png|15px]] Discussion ongoing.
  
  +
|[[File:Neutral.png|15px]] Pending implementation.
 
|-
  
|-
  +
|96
−
|colspan="3" align="center"|'''Part VI'''
  
  +
|Emotions for users in chat
−
<!--
  
  +
|
  +
|[[File:Neutral.png|15px]] Pending discussion
 
|-
  
|-
−
|colspan="3" align="center"|[[Thread:######|Click here to make suggestions]]
 +
|colspan="3" align="center"|[[Thread:123519|Part VIII]]
−
-->
 +
|-
  +
|97
  +
|Change "kudos"
  +
|
  +
|[[File:Neutral.png|15px]] Pending discussion.
  +
|-
  +
|98
  +
|ExtendedNavigation
  +
|
  +
|[[File:Neutral.png|15px]] Pending discussion.
  +
|-
  +
|99
  +
|Title card database
  +
|
  +
|[[File:Neutral.png|15px]] Pending discussion.
  +
|-
  +
|100
  +
|Enable Top 10 lists
  +
|
  +
|[[File:Neutral.png|15px]] Pending discussion.
  +
|-
  +
|101
  +
|Wikia maps
  +
|
  +
|[[File:Neutral.png|15px]] Pending discussion.
  +
|-
  +
|102
  +
|"New badges for the following categories: all galleries, discussions, events, VHS, and amusement rides"
  +
|
  +
|[[File:Neutral.png|15px]] Pending discussion.
  +
|-
  +
|colspan="3" align="center"|[[Thread:129341|Part IX]]
  +
|-
  +
|colspan="3" align="center"|[[Thread:129341|Click here to make suggestions]]
  +
{{S-list
  +
|number = 103
  +
|user = Squilliam Fancyson
  +
|status = [[File:Neutral.png|15px]]
  +
|status-details = Pending discussion
  +
|suggestion = I know that some people might not consider this an important change, but I kind of find it annoying that certain character descriptions make the characters sound as if they are superhuman rather than typical cartoon characters. For instance; on Gary's page is states "Gary can levitate and teleport", which makes him sound like he posses superpowers, when in reality he is just a cartoon being a cartoon. Something like that could be simplified to "Like many animated characters, Gary can occasionally be seen defying the laws of science, as seen in the episode 'Gary Takes a Bath'." I'm not asking to quote me, but something along the lines of that. This isn't just seen on Gary's page either. On SpongeBob's page it states "SpongeBob has displayed some forms of telepathy". These are just animated characters who aren't meant to be taken that seriously.
  +
}}
  +
{{S-list
  +
|number = 104
  +
|user = Squilliam Fancyson
  +
|status = [[File:Neutral.png|15px]]
  +
|status-details = Pending discussion
  +
|suggestion = Many characters have traits described on their page, making them seem permanent. Another example is on Gary's page where it states "Gary has arms, as seen in "Have You Seen This Snail?", "The Gift of Gum", and "Grooming Gary". Just because they were used as temporary gags, doesn't mean that they are permanent traits. It also says that he has a record player underneath his shell, along with many other objects, which could be simplified to "The contents of Gary's shell have varied throughout the series."
  +
}}
  +
{{S-list
  +
|number = 105
  +
|user = Nicko756
  +
|status = [[File:Neutral.png|15px]]
  +
|status-details = Postponed
  +
|suggestion = PageRenameAuto-Update
  +
}}
  +
{{S-list
  +
|number = 106
  +
|user = Nicko756
  +
|status = [[File:Oppose.png|15px]]
  +
|status-details = '''DISMISSED'''
  +
|suggestion = Username templates that link to userpages.
  +
}}
  +
{{S-list
  +
|number = 107
  +
|user = Nicko756
  +
|status = [[File:Oppose.png|15px]]
  +
|status-details = '''DISMISSED'''
  +
|suggestion = SpongeBobia Pass
  +
}}
  +
{{S-list
  +
|number = 108
  +
|user = Nicko756
  +
|status = [[File:Neutral.png|15px]]
  +
|status-details = Postponed.
  +
|suggestion = Quote of the day on the home page
  +
}}
  +
{{S-list
  +
|number = 109
  +
|user = Nicko756
  +
|status = [[File:Oppose.png|15px]]
  +
|status-details = Dismissed.
  +
|suggestion = Name for [[Special:Leaderboard]]
  +
}}
  +
{{S-list
  +
|number = 110
  +
|user = Nicko756
  +
|status = [[File:Oppose.png|15px]]
  +
|status-details = Dismissed.
  +
|suggestion = For tasks, change the point value of UOTM from 2,000 to 1,000.
  +
}}
  +
|-
  +
|colspan="3" align="center"|[[Thread:129341|Part X]]
  +
|-
  +
|colspan="3" align="center"|[[Thread:129341|Click here to make suggestions]]
  +
{{S-list
  +
|number = 111
  +
|user = Auron~Guardian
  +
|status = [[File:Oppose.png|15px]]
  +
|status-details = '''DISMISSED'''
  +
|suggestion = 4 separate SpongeTokens Leaderboards (Overall, users, contests, tasks)
  +
}}
  +
{{S-list
  +
|number = 112
  +
|user = 120d
  +
|status = [[File:Neutral.png|15px]]
  +
|status-details = Under discussion
  +
|suggestion = Locations guideline page
  +
}}
  +
{{S-list
  +
|number = 113
  +
|user = 120d
  +
|status = [[File:Oppose.png|15px]]
  +
|status-details = '''DISMISSED'''
  +
|suggestion = "I think that, unless it is super serious, there should be a period of time, before a user can get blocked after being blocked one or more times."
  +
}}
 
|}
  
|}
   
−
<!--
 +
----
  +
Other things to discuss:
−
*Edit summary rule
  
  +
*1) Question of character links in episode articles
−
:*This could be a recommendation, but this is not something that would be easy to enforce and would discourage contributions
  
  +
*2) Code for star ratings ([http://code.tutsplus.com/tutorials/building-a-5-star-rating-system-with-jquery-ajax-and-php--net-11541])
−
*Roles for actors
  
−
:*It was agreed upon in a chat meeting that it does not hurt to have all information on an actor. Of course, guests just go on this list.
  
−
*Poll for rating episodes
  
−
:*Research for this is still underway
  
−
*Discussion for italicizing or quoting episode names.
  
−
*Subgalleries project
  
−
:*All that needs to be done is to create a project page, and then it can be advertised for interested contributors to see.
  
−
*"Once a fact that is "this is the ___ time that _____", has reached 11 times, I think it can no longer be a fact like that and should be removed because by that point it does not become rare enough to point it out."
  
−
*"I think that the descussion feed needs to return back to the Discussion Box on the front page."
  
−
:*I am currently working on a system that will notify users of ESB news much more effectively.
  
−
*"I think that admins and beurocrats should wait until the last couple of days before they can vote on discussions (not including background contests). That way, people will be able to vote without being influenced by admins or beurocrats. (You can support a discussion without voting on it)"
  
−
:*It's mostly admins and bureaucrats that contribute to the discussions anyway. How is there influence?
  
−
*"There should be a rule that says that people cannot create duplicated images."
  
−
:*It's basically a given thing. If someone does this, they don't need to be blocked, just told that they uploaded a duplicate image. There are so many images here, for some users might not know that they uploaded a duplicate.
  
−
*"I think instead of creating pages for background characters from scratch we use the pages that now contain the redirects because most contain a version of the page we are looking for."
  
−
:*That is the intention.
  
−
*"A recent example is the "quotes rule" this rule is apparently a rule where names of Episodes, Shorts, and Rides have to be quoted on their main page."
  
−
:*120d - what do you mean?
  
−
*"I think that we should have a redo on the name scheme discussion."
 
−
:*You are the only one who had an issue with this, 120d.
 
−
*Category Super Heroes > Superheroes
  
−
:*I will get my bot to change this.
  
−
-->
  
   
 
[[Category:Community]]
  
[[Category:Community]]

Revision as of 18:28, 6 September 2017


Wiki
Archive
The following page has been archived. Please do not edit this page.

Encyclopedia SpongeBobia
Wiki
General
Policies
Community
Manual of style
Administration
  • Administrators
  • Requests
  • Reviews
Nominations
Social chatrooms
Other
Main page

Welcome to the suggestions page. At ESB, everyone's ideas are welcome and considered. Post your ideas on the designated threads and your suggestion will be brought up at one of the meetings and discussed. This page lists all such suggestions and their status.


# User Status
UPDATED SEPTEMBER 21, 2014
Part I
1 Lemony gemmy (Wall) Support Accepted.
More background contests.
2 Koolkitty108 (Wall) Oppose Too complex
Slide show alongside galleries.
3 JCM (Wall) Support PASSED (see archive)
Main page redesign.
4 120d (Wall) Support PASSED (see archive)
May 3, 2014 - Redirects for usernames.
5 120d (Wall) Oppose Technical issues
May 3, 2014 - All info boxes with set image sizes.
6 Carkle100 (Wall) Neutral Pending completion
May 3, 2014 - Wiki history in navigation
7 Timjames98 (Wall) Support PASSED (see archive)
May 3, 2014 - Minor characters with their own pages.
8 120d (Wall) Neutral Pending creation.
May 4, 2014 - User tutorial
9 Spongebob456 (Wall) Support PASSED (see archive)
May 4, 2014 - Awards (such as user of the month)
10 Spongebob456 (Wall) Support PASSED (see archive)
May 4, 2014 - Article of the month
11 Ssj4gogita4 (Wall) Oppose DISMISSED
May 4, 2014 - Redesign the entire wiki.
Part II
12 Muchacha (Wall) Neutral Postponed.
May 5, 2014 - Episode reviews and analysis
13 120d (Wall) Support Bot run complete.
May 11, 2014 - Replace </references> with {{Reflist}}
14 SpongeyTube (Wall) Oppose DISMISSED
May 11, 2014 - Auto Refresh Wiki Activity
15 120d (Wall) Oppose DISMISSED
May 17, 2014 - Eliminate moral/legal issues listed in articles.
Part III
16 120d (Wall) Oppose DISMISSED
May 19, 2014 - Changing of proposal times.
17 Lemony gemmy (Wall) Oppose No specified alternative.
May 19, 2014 - Change of yellow in theme.
18 Muchacha (Wall) Oppose "Teams" never really worked before; efforts are being made to eliminate stubs.
May 20, 2014 - Cleanup team to eliminate stubs.
19 120d (Wall) Support ACCEPTED
May 20, 2014 - Crossover characters list
20 120d (Wall) Oppose DISMISSED
May 21, 2014 - Defining cultural references.
21 AW10 (Wall) Oppose (see archive) CANCELLED
May 21, 2014 - Changing infobox colors.
22 120d (Wall) Neutral Pending discussion.
May 25, 2014 - Using SBM ratings in reception.
23 AW10 (Wall) Support Implemented.
May 25, 2014 - Remove text-align:justify.
Part IV (May 26, 2014)
24 Muchacha (Wall) Oppose Rejected.
May 28, 2014 - Restore article comments.
25 Greatlegoman29 (Wall) Neutral Pending ideas.
May 28, 2014 - Rebuild SpongeBob SquarePants (series) article.
26 120d (Wall) Oppose REJECTED: (see archive)
June 4, 2014 - Downsizing filmography lists on people articles.
27 120d (Wall) Oppose REJECTED
June 4, 2014 - Adding a discussion notification on main page.
28 Muchacha (Wall) Support ACCEPTED
June 8, 2014 - Using photos in synopsis sections.
29 Muchacha (Wall) Neutral Pending discussion.
June 8, 2014 - Returning quote sections to episode articles.
30 Muchacha (Wall) Oppose DISMISSED
June 8, 2014 - Separate trivia and errors to another page.
31 120d (Wall) Oppose REJECTED (see archive)
June 8, 2014 - Separate SpongeBob SquarePants internet phenomena into tabs.
Part V
32 Aliases in their own section Support Accepted
33 Use of discussion formatting as AW10 has done at FSB Support Impletmented
34 Changing User to "Employee" of the Month Oppose Dismissed
35 Poll of the week Support Accepted.
36 Changing the time limit between admin requests Oppose Dismissed.
37 Automatic deleting system Oppose Dismissed.
38 Stub length Support 1,000 bytes (see archive)
39 Require edit summaries Oppose Dismissed.
40 Episode ratings on articles Neutral Pending ideas.
41 Italicize vs. Quoting episode titles Support Quoting (see archive)
42 Subgalleries project Support A project page can be created.
43 Fact limits on ___ time that ___ happened. Oppose Dismissed.
44 Delayed administrative participation in discussions Oppose REJECTED: (see archive)
45 Restore character pages from redirects Support Accepted and encouraged
Part VI
46 Viewership in lists Neutral Pending implementation.
47 Rollback requests Oppose Dismissed.
48 Display clock Support Accepted.
49 Voice output Oppose REJECTED: (see archive)
50 Trivia quizzes Support Accepted.
51 BackToTopArrow Support PASSED: (see archive)
52 Changing terminology for signed in/not signed users Oppose Dismissed.
53 Character hover designs Support PASSED: (see archive)
54 "Episodes that focus on <character>" categories Oppose Dismissed.
55 Require people to give reason for their options in discussions Oppose Dismissed.
56 All images in one category Oppose Dismissed.
57 Galleryheadings on appearance articles Oppose Dismissed.
58 Separate TV movies from episodes Oppose Dismissed.
59 OTab Oppose REJECTED: (see archive)
60 More usertags Support Accepted.
61 Season navigation templates Oppose Dismissed.
62 Change rating system to go along with the additional "Strong Support," "Weak Support," etc. Oppose Dismissed.
63 Add iTunes release date and link to "release" section. Support Accepted.
64 Custom cursors Oppose Dismissed.
65 ReferencePopups Support Accepted.
66 "Tournaments" on certain topics (best episode, etc.) Neutral Pending discussion.
67 Change sides of entire site Support PASSED: (see archive)
Part VII
68 Day/night chat Oppose Dismissed.
69 AutoEditDropdown Oppose Dismissed.
70 ImageAnnotator Oppose Dismissed.
71 FileUsageAuto-update Oppose Dismissed.
72 DynamicImages Neutral Pending implementation
73 FloatingToc Neutral Pending implementation
74 CGI video on main page Oppose Dismissed.
75 MiniComplete Neutral Pending implementation
76 Places listing on episode articles Oppose Dismissed.
77 Appearance tables for locations Support Accepted.
78 Tables for character appearance totals Neutral Save for future.
79 Episode disambiguations (episode) Oppose Dismissed.
80 Separated character templates Neutral Dismissed for another idea (bottom episode templates)
81 Pages for the pirates from the movie Support Single page accepted.
82 Film trailer on main page. Oppose Dismissed.
83 Puncuation list Support Accepted.
84 Image categories for episodes Support Accepted.
85 "I think we shouldn't allow any general reception of episodes. I think it should all be sourced and about certain reviewers." Neutral Pending discussion
86 Adopt 3 revert rule from Wikipedia Neutral Pending discussion
87 Slogan change Support Accepted.
88 Requests for block page (or change ban to block, or change to abuse report) Neutral Pending implementation.
89 Show/hide for templates on bottom of page. Neutral Pending implementation.
90 "Episode galleries should be reordered and named sequentially." Support Accepted.
91 "In addition to this, all episode errors should be listed in the order they appear for that episode." Oppose Dismissed.
92 "How about we organize all tabs on List of characters like it is organized for List of merchandise/videos?" Neutral Pending discussion
93 "I also suggest we create a rule that on message walls, discussion boards, forums and everywhere same system is used, if you want to quote somone, never do a double quote, only qoute the message you are replying to." Neutral Pending discussion
94 Updating the "Multiple Accounts" policy. Neutral Pending discussion
95 Link spongebobia.wikia.com at www.spongebobia.com Neutral Pending implementation.
96 Emotions for users in chat Neutral Pending discussion
Part VIII
97 Change "kudos" Neutral Pending discussion.
98 ExtendedNavigation Neutral Pending discussion.
99 Title card database Neutral Pending discussion.
100 Enable Top 10 lists Neutral Pending discussion.
101 Wikia maps Neutral Pending discussion.
102 "New badges for the following categories: all galleries, discussions, events, VHS, and amusement rides" Neutral Pending discussion.
Part IX
Click here to make suggestions
103 Squilliam Fancyson (Wall) Neutral Pending discussion
I know that some people might not consider this an important change, but I kind of find it annoying that certain character descriptions make the characters sound as if they are superhuman rather than typical cartoon characters. For instance; on Gary's page is states "Gary can levitate and teleport", which makes him sound like he posses superpowers, when in reality he is just a cartoon being a cartoon. Something like that could be simplified to "Like many animated characters, Gary can occasionally be seen defying the laws of science, as seen in the episode 'Gary Takes a Bath'." I'm not asking to quote me, but something along the lines of that. This isn't just seen on Gary's page either. On SpongeBob's page it states "SpongeBob has displayed some forms of telepathy". These are just animated characters who aren't meant to be taken that seriously.
104 Squilliam Fancyson (Wall) Neutral Pending discussion
Many characters have traits described on their page, making them seem permanent. Another example is on Gary's page where it states "Gary has arms, as seen in "Have You Seen This Snail?", "The Gift of Gum", and "Grooming Gary". Just because they were used as temporary gags, doesn't mean that they are permanent traits. It also says that he has a record player underneath his shell, along with many other objects, which could be simplified to "The contents of Gary's shell have varied throughout the series."
105 Nicko756 (Wall) Neutral Postponed
PageRenameAuto-Update
106 Nicko756 (Wall) Oppose DISMISSED
Username templates that link to userpages.
107 Nicko756 (Wall) Oppose DISMISSED
SpongeBobia Pass
108 Nicko756 (Wall) Neutral Postponed.
Quote of the day on the home page
109 Nicko756 (Wall) Oppose Dismissed.
Name for Special:Leaderboard
110 Nicko756 (Wall) Oppose Dismissed.
For tasks, change the point value of UOTM from 2,000 to 1,000.
Part X
Click here to make suggestions
111 Auron~Guardian (Wall) Oppose DISMISSED
4 separate SpongeTokens Leaderboards (Overall, users, contests, tasks)
112 120d (Wall) Neutral Under discussion
Locations guideline page
113 120d (Wall) Oppose DISMISSED
"I think that, unless it is super serious, there should be a period of time, before a user can get blocked after being blocked one or more times."

Other things to discuss:

  • 1) Question of character links in episode articles
  • 2) Code for star ratings ([1])
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.