Support  – I don’t like the neglect at the beginning, and the spoiled milk made no sense and was kinda gross, but good episode. - JustYes
Support  – It was a great episode. I feel sorry for Gary when he ran away after SpongeBob forgets to feed him. And SpongeBob after he felt bad about what he did to Gary. And that song "Gary, Come Home" sure was sad. But at least Gary is back with SpongeBob.--Jokeman20 (talk) 21:11, May 3, 2019 (UTC)
Support  – Pretty heartbreaking episode for the most part and what helps is that SpongeBob genuinely feels bad for neglecting Gary and goes through hoops to find him. ZeoSparkTalkContribsEdits 21:15,5/3/2019
Support  – Everything is just great about this episode. AK World (talk)
Support  – <This episode kind of goes to two extremes, but it's still one that you can watch a few times>Nematodesarepeopletoo
Oppose  – NEJ, not happening, not on my watch, this episode can't win, I won't let it, I will do everything I can to make it lose, kick it off now AlternativeHuman93(M•C•E) 00:23, May 4, 2019 (UTC)
Comment - excellent reasoning that definitely warrants the lowest possible rating. Chuck123456(M•C•E) 09:28, May 4, 2019 (UTC)
Support  – Great.
Support  – Everything is great about the episode. The plot, the humour, the emotions, the song... do I have to say any more?
Support  – An absolute masterpiece, and my favourite episode of the entire series. It handled a fairly interesting and relatable plot incredibly well, because even though the episode focused on the story more than the humor, it still felt like it belongs in the show, and there were still some really funny and memorable jokes, my favourite of them being "It's the apocalypse! Office products falling from the sky!". The plot itself was very emotional and it really made me feel what SpongeBob felt. It had some really hearthbreaking scenes, such as SpongeBob realising what he did to Gary, and the song, which is the greatest song in the show, along with Goofy Goober Rock. The story was absolutely excellent, because it was one of the few episodes which really made me feel, and that made the ending, when SpongeBob found Gary, even better. If any episode should win, it is this one. I can't praise it enough. Doctor Patrick(M•C•E) 09:59, May 4, 2019 (UTC)
Support  – Great episode, touching, has some memorable gags. Daud 12:32, May 4, 2019 (UTC)
Support  – Oh! The song - BaldiBasicsFan
Oppose  – Just because something is emotional doesn’t make it good. This episode is manipulative - SpongeBob never goes this far and it never should be. This is something like “Life of Brian” from Family Guy (although not as bad). It’s sole purpose is to make you feel bad. Do I feel bad for SpongeBob? No, not at all. Whatever they tried to do with this one, it doesn’t work for me. DanzxvFan8275 (M•C•U•E) 14:06, May 4, 2019 (UTC)