The following chat moderator request has been closed. The page has been protected and now serves as an archive. Do not edit this page.
User requesting chat moderator: Emen383 Date discussion closed: December 30, 2019 Result of discussion: Unsuccessful.
a. Why do you believe you are qualified to be promoted to this position?
I am very diligent in everything I do, and I want to do my best to add value to this Wikia's chatroom and use my moderator rights to accomplish what I believe the general community would like me to accomplish. I have a lot of experience using chatrooms. I have dealt with my fair share of trolls and other issues and helped moderators execute their duties by letting them know when there was a troll.
b. Have you had experience with this position before?
I have not exactly been a moderator, but I have experience assisting moderators. I also used to be a lunch and recess monitor.
c. What are your best contributions to Encyclopedia SpongeBobia and why?
I think a lot of my contributions added value in different ways. I think my most valuable ones are those that correct the sentence structure. I cannot say that there is one contribution that is better than the rest because they all help in different ways.
d. How do you plan to use your rights if your request is successful?
I will use my rights to help this Wikia's chatroom be a popular hangout place. I will make sure all rules are abided by because that is part of making it a fun place for everyone.
e. Have you been in a situation in which you needed the user rights for this position at that moment but were unable to act?
I actually have. There have been a couple of times when a spammer comes and begins to flood the room, and all I am able to do it request the presence of a moderator or administrator.
f. Is there anything else you want to add?
I want to help out on this Wikia in anyway I can. I know that whatever I do, I can do very well at because I take great pride in everything I do. I can be here whenever necessary. There is absolutely no limit to how much time I can be here. I truly want to help this Wikia achieve its maximum potential.
Extremely Strong Oppose - Just please no. I respect the idea that the skill should be involved but you haven’t PROVED that you have it. Being a lunch and recess monitor is way different than being a chat mod because there isn’t much of a recess edition of trolls or something like that lol. Also I’ve NEVER seen you discuss SpongeBob aside from the time you said you DON’T WATCH the show. Also I don’t trust that you know everything about the show because of which. When you do rarely talk, it’s about things that weren’t in the conversation and your things about grandkids while interesting do not contribute to what is going on and feels more like interruption. Especially because it’s ALL you EVER talk about and you never let these things go! And while in chat a fair amount you hardly talk! From your spam of these requests I don’t trust you and saying that you will help is not proof. Also, an answer of “no” to E just means you don’t need the rights! And I hate to use this argument, but there are already 5 chat mods and many admins who can do this. Not to mention, for “best contributions,” you really haven’t made a huge amount. I’m sorry, hard oppose. Also, it being Christmas changes nothing in the slightest.
Comment - Also just saying, don't tell people not to vote if it's an oppose, that makes me trust you even less.
Comment - *And is also against the rules and can deem your request as invalid. -- 16:06, December 23, 2019 (UTC)
Oppose - "Do I need to say it?" -- 15:59, December 23, 2019 (UTC)
Extremely Strong Oppose - I’m sorry, but I don’t think you’re fit for this position right now. You are in chat a lot but you barely even TALK there, and when you do, it is NEVER about SpongeBob. You always interrupt conversations by telling us what your grandchildren are doing, or that you want to talk about administrator requirements. Which, most of the time, has NOTHING to do what anybody is talking about. And you constantly say “it isn’t about the requirements, it’s about the skill” ALL THE TIME. You always bring that up in chat and it gets VERY annoying. And yeah, skill is something you need to become a chat moderator or admin, but you need to PROVE you have that skill first instead of blatantly saying you have it. And, I barely see you talk about SpongeBob AT ALL. The only time I have seen you talk about SpongeBob is when the chatroom TOLD you, because you were annoying them with your interruptions that had to do with your grandchildren. You have also said in the chat before that you barely watch the show at ALL, and you just joined to get admin. You have been doing this for almost THREE years now. Don’t you think it’s time to stop?
Comment - I just looked at your previous chat mod request and this current one and each answer here is the EXACT same as your previous one. I'm switching to extremely strong oppose because laziness like this deserves the maximum amount of oppose. Mavnol333(W•C•L•E)
Strong Oppose - This is a poor request, even compared to the last one. I don't think you've improved at all at answering these, and I don't believe you'll fit the job at all. AlternativeHuman93(M•C•E) 16:19, December 23, 2019 (UTC)
Extremely RAAL-ishly Strong Oppose - First of all, you say you've never been in a situation [in which you needed the blah blah whatever...], so that means you wouldn't know how to react. Second, watching "every single" episode of Spongebob[sic] does NOT make you capable of managing a wiki's chat. Third, you already did 2 bureaucrat requests and 8 admin requests, yet they were all unsuccessful/invalid. Also, you don't have enough experience, in my opinion. Sharko(W•C•E) 16:43, December 23, 2019 (UTC)
Oppose - A: No. B: Too many chat moderators. C: Per CM26, being a lunch and recess monitor is different from being a chat mod. Trolls aren’t around in lunch or recess, wouldn’t you think? D: Come on, just because it’s Christmas time doesn’t mean there will be any differences. Though, I personally put Oppose instead of Extremely Strong Oppose because you are improving little by little. -JoJoMKWUTeam(W•C•E) 16:53, December 23, 2019 (UTC)
Extremely Strong Oppose - Per everyone. You always say that the requirements don't matter because you are skilled enough to be a chat moderator, but you have still failed to show this skill. Also, you don't contribute to chat very well, as you barely chat at all, and when you do, you are always off topic and constantly mentioning how you want to become a chat moderator/administrator. You also don't make very many edits, or do hardly anything on the wiki aside from sitting silently in chat. I don't think you are ready for this position for these reasons. Also, the answers on your request do not convince me or the admins anything. If you answer "no" to question E, it just proves that you do not need chat moderator rights at all. This request is poor even compared to your last one. While I voted neutral on your previous request, which was actually decent, the answers here show no sign of effort or thought. You technically meet the requirements, but this request is so subpar that I cannot do anything but oppose it. I'm sorry, but you definitely do not need chat moderator rights at this time. PlanKrab(W•C•E) 11:52 AM, December 23, 2019 (EST)
Extremely Strong Oppose - ɨɖʀօքքɛɖʍʏքɛռ 16:59, December 23, 2019 (UTC)
Extremely Strong Oppose - Agreed with everyone's reasoning above that I don't believe that you'll be fit for a job like that. :— 1033Forest[talk] 17:03, December 23, 2019 (UTC)
Extremely Strong Oppose - Figmeister(W•C•E) 17:11, December 23, 2019 (UTC)
Extremely Strong Oppose - I don't think there is anyone who comes to chat regularly who is less qualified than you are for this role. There is no need for you to have it. Doratron 9001.1.2 (talk) 19:03, December 23, 2019 (UTC)
Strong Oppose - WILL YOU STOP MAKING THESE REQUESTS? In case you don't know, there's more to contributing to a wiki than being admin. You never talk about SpongeBob and all you talk about is being admin and your grandkids. You keep complaining that "it's not all about the requirements" when you should realize that admin isn't a position you can hand out to anyone. You've been doing this for a couple of years now and you haven't learned your lesson. Supposedly you've done this thing on other wikis as well. I'm sorry but I really do not want you to make any more promotion requests for a while. Louis219(W•C•E) 23:50, December 24, 2019 (UTC)
Oppose - you have applied for staff 13 times before and I can tell that not even one has passed and that your answers were not clear at all also for b that's a in real life problem problem not a internet problem. SpongeTron D(W•C•E) 05:05, December 25, 2019 (UTC)
Strong Oppose - You've been frequently requesting positions since Autumn 2017, despite your lack of qualifications. This is just another example of a preposterous request on display. (Contact • Contrib) 04:29, December 26, 2019 (UTC)
Strong Oppose - You have done this too many times. Plus, I see you in the chat many times but I hardly see you ever talk. Spongefan14 (talk)
Comment - I understand you want to help and all, but it's just you don't seem fit for the role, and if you think so you haven't proven it yet. Maybe it's time to lay off the requests for a while. And it's probably time to close this. - JustYes, who needs to get off this iPad. It's Christmas
Reply - It should have ended yesterday, actually.IloGaming4(M•C•E)
12:12, December 25, 2019 (UTC)
Comment - "I actually have. There have been a couple of times when a spammer comes and begins to flood the room, and all I am able to do it request the presence of a moderator or administrator." "I have dealt with my fair share of trolls and other issues and helped moderators execute their duties by letting them know when there was a troll." I don't recall you ever doing these things. You never actually talk in chat.IloGaming4(M•C•E)
12:16, December 25, 2019 (UTC)
Comment - Emen, basically all we're saying is start talking in chat more and try not to annoy others and/or be off topic. Mavnol333(W•C•L•E)
Comment - We know your true goal of becoming admin, despite you knowing pretty much nothing about the show. Knowing the characters is far from enough. AlternativeHuman93(M•C•E) 06:17, December 27, 2019 (UTC)